Quick links:
- Home
- E+T Magazine Issues
- Volume 19, Issue 6 - November/December 2024
3D Modelling
Construction Industry
Football
Sport
Open-access content Heidi Vella —
Mon 23 Dec 2024
The 4D model for the stand during week 85. The stadium has effectively been built digitally, then in real life. Image credit | Bentley Systems
Construction of Everton FC’s new £555m stadium has relied on the novel use of 4D modelling technology, which is credited with helping to keep the project on schedule and within budget.
Football stadiums bear witness to spectacle and, often, pure drama. For Everton last season, there was plenty of both. With the club in the process of building a new 52,888-seat stadium on Liverpool’s Bramley-Moore Dock, they had a total of eight points deducted for breaching financial rules. Itlooked at one stage that this new ground would not be visited by Premier League clubs any time soon until a much-needed end-of-season surge saw the Toffees narrowly retain their top-flight status.
Building stadiums can be equally precarious, says SimonBeards, the principal planner for the new £555m venue, which is being constructed by engineers Laing O’Rourke. He points to Tottenham Hotspur’s show-stopping stadium that started with an early budget of £250m, but was completed three years later in 2019 for an eye-watering £1.2bn amid delays and controversies. Then there’s the Millennium Stadium in Cardiff (now known as Principality Stadium), which was delivered on time but effectively bankrupted contractor Laing. It was purchased for £1 by O’Rourke to become Laing O’Rourke.
The Everton Stadium project has so far managed to avoid such controversies. Construction has now entered its home straight and is both on schedule and within budget, with nearly 12,000 construction staff required during thebuild.
Everton’s East Stand during week 85 of the build. The 4D model allowed the project delivery team to visualise the construction sequence. Image credit | Bentley Systems
Collaborative digital environment
Beards in part credits the project’s successful progress to the use of 4D modelling. Three-dimensional building informationmodelling (3D BIM) shows how a building looks or will look, while 4D modelling adds in time, such as construction and schedule-related information, to visualise how the building will be erected over certain periods.Everything is shared in a common data environment such as the cloud.
With 4D modelling, it is usually only used as a bidding tool to essentially ‘wow’ the client and is then forgotten about, says Beards. However, on the Everton project the 4D model, almost by accident, became integral to the entire construction process.
“Someone said, ‘Why don’t we put it in the immersive room?’ So we did and I was thinking, ‘Oh crikey, I don’t want people to see my mistakes,’” says Beards. “Then the penny dropped – that’s the whole point. If you see your mistakes digitally, you’ve got an opportunity to correct them.” From then on, the stadium was effectively built twice: digitally first then in real life.
The immersive room, built by the company Immersive, was originally created for staff training and induction. It’s not VR but several projectors display the Gantt chart – the original project planning tool – on to one wall and the 4D model on to another. The Gantt chart live programme is synced to the 4D model so the team can see images and sequences of work that have taken place or are about to happen. Drones are used to collect regular footage so the construction progress can be married up to the digital image to ensure it is up to date.
The building programme has around 30,000 activities, which can be difficult to track and monitor, but the resulting 4D model allows the project delivery team to visualise the construction sequence and improve communication overall.
“It became the next generation ofmeetings,” says Beards. “It was no longer the planner’s programme, but engaged the whole team.”
But the main benefit is logistical. Using the model, the team can assess potential risks and clashes in the construction programme, as well as see opportunities they might have missed using the Gantt chart alone. This is particularly advantageous given the project has a high use of cranes. This is, in part, due to its design for manufacture and assembly agenda, which has a target for 70% or more of products – such as pre-cast concrete terrace units and external brickwork panels – to be built in a factory environment to reduce waste. These are then lifted into the building. Reduced access due to the waterfront location on the River Mersey also adds further logistical challenges.
“We’re building on the side of a dock with a lot of wind exposure. Depending on the weather things will go slower or quicker, which impacts crane timings,” explains Beards. “If you get the crane and logistical strategy right, the wheels keep turning. The worst thing is falling behind on the Friday and the following week a crane turns up, and the old crane is still costing thousands.”
In the 4D model, cranes could be seen getting on top of each other so the team were able to adjust the schedule to avoid potential clashes.
“If I could list how many incidents and situations where we’ve had that sort ofissue and we’ve prevented it, it would be as long as my arm,” says Beards.
Sub-contractors such as Severfield, which provided the steel superstructure, also have access to the 4D platform and immersive meetings. They can submit their programme of work directly into the software so it can automatically be built into the wider plan.
“That single source of truth – having one programme everyone can view – keeps the project dynamic,” says Beards.
Into the future
Bentley Systems’ CEO Greg Bentley. Image credit | www.marygardella.com
Where to next?
It is believed around 25% of the construction sector is embracing the use of 4D modelling technology during the construction phase. About a decade ago, the industry was using 1,000-line Gantt charts stuck on a wall and moved along with a string, according to Beards.
Adoption is expected to grow further along with the technology itself. Nick Wilson, senior enterprise account manager at Bentley Systems, said at the opening of the company’s 8 Bishopsgate headquarters that the industry is only “scratching the surface of what 4D can do” and that the technology has “supercharged their forward thinking”.
In principle, with some coding knowledge an infinite amount of detail can be added to the models, said John Nolan,regional asset data analysis manager for Network Rail, who was speaking at the event. He said as part ofthe handover of asset data the company is asking for ‘as-built models’ and drawings located in the common data environment. “We are going to use that information to keep our asset twins up to date and to also give us the geospatial location of all our assets,” he said.
But most of the value lies in the data, which is itself an asset. The data with AI could be used to build components and structures quicker, instead of always starting from scratch, he added.
Network Rail uses ProjectWise, a Bentley Systems application, to store its entire project data, as does engineering firm Mott MacDonald. Bentley Systems’ CEO Greg Bentley agrees training AI presents an “auspicious opportunity”.
“AI can look back through engineers’ previous projects and reuse it, find and suggest and parameterise and modularise,” he says. “Where you have good data, you can apply it with AI in ways that we didn’t anticipate.”
This doesn’t mean an AI model will replace engineers, but that each organisation will benefit from its own data, he adds. “This could help address the engineering skills gap and be used for training co-pilots to support engineers,” Bentley says.
The company worked out that engineering firms spend about $1.50 an hour for the engineer to use its programmes, but the engineer costs 100 times that much.
Engineers are understandably wary of this kind of technology trajectory. Forexample, Beards says: “At what point do we give the computer all the power about how you build it? When do we stop thinking as humans? You’re always going to have to check it.”
Construction of the newstadium has now entered its home straight and is both on schedule and within budget
Next generation tool
The Everton Stadium project has garnered international attention, receiving visits from those interested in adopting its approach, including from Australia, the Middle East, Japan and across the UK. Beards is also tutoring others on how to use the technology, saying he can train anyone in 15 minutes.
“The question everyone asks is how much the cost would be without the 4D model,” he says. “But it’s an impossible question to answer because it’s real-life engineering where the impact didn’t happen.”
The 4D model Laing O’Rourke is using is part of Bentley Systems’ infrastructure construction management software SYNCHRO. It was acquired by the company initially for use on London’s Crossrail project. Lendlease also used it on the construction of Bentley Systems’ new UK head office, a 50-storey tower on the corner of Bishopsgate and Leadenhall Street in London, which was unveiled in May. Known as 8 Bishopsgate, the block comprises 52,900m2 of office space. It was built digitally first using the programme, which Lendlease says helped the team reduce the construction time by six weeks.
Laing O’Rourke has said it will use the technology to deliver complex construction projects in the future and it is currently looking at how to use it for the fit-out stage to monitor walls going up and flooring going down. But there are challenges. File sizes can be huge – the current 4D is 500-600MB – and the fit-out model will require larger files and better hardware. Beards is working with Bentley Systems to improve on the software suite further. In addition, depending on the type of project, data sent from different departments may need to be standardised.
“We are trying to learn what’s gonewell in this project because stadiums arehistorically difficult to build, andcertainly on the side of a dock,” saysBeards. “But I have seen the value this technology has brought really quickly and I hope this will become a tool used by the next generation and essentially the new norm.”
Everton Stadium Development Ltd
Value £555m
Starting date 26.07.21
Completion date 20.12.24
Programme duration 178 weeks
This article appeared in the Volume 19, Issue 6 - November/December 2024 issue of E+T Magazine.
Click here to view this issue
- UK government pledges to turbocharge planning decisions on 150 infrastructure projects
- IET Comment: Is e-voting in the UK on the horizon?
- How France rebuilt Notre-Dame: Blending medieval craftsmanship with cutting-edge tech
You may also be interested in...
Interview: MIT's chaplain says tech has become 'the world’s most powerful religion'
Thu 2 Jan 2025
Humanist chaplain at Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), Greg Epstein believes that technology – more accurately ‘tech’ – has become the 21st century’s most powerful global religion. He also believes it’s time it had its own Reformation.
Open-access content
Stratospheric balloons offer space tourism’s alternative to glamping
Thu 2 Jan 2025
Stratospheric balloons are cheaper and easier to build than rockets and spaceplanes. They can offer hours of magnificent views ofthe Earth from within a comfy space capsule. But something has been holding their developers back.
Open-access content
From the archives: The invention of Christmas tree lights, the first steam train ride
Thu 12 Dec 2024
Tanya Weaver looks back at a fiery start for the steam locomotive, the beginnings of a Christmas tradition and ‘genius’ Hertha Ayrton
Open-access content
Mineral deficiency: Solving the shortage in rare earths
Mon 9 Dec 2024
Due to a dwindling supply of ‘rare earth’ metals, vital in green technologies such as wind turbines, new approaches to design, sourcing andrecycling are now required.
Open-access content
Evil Engineer: Can I trigger a new ice age?
Mon 6 Jan 2025
The most feasible approach for bringing about a new period of glacial growth.
Open-access content
Will online voting make the UK more democratic?
Mon 2 Dec 2024
Only 52% of people voted in the UK general election this year. Is that enough in a democracy, and – if not – is online voting the answer to making Britain’s voting system more democratic?
Open-access content
IET comment: Will GB Energy deliver?
Thu 28 Nov 2024
Professor Peter Bannister, chair of the IET Sustainability and Net Zero Policy Centre, says Labour has bold plans for the energy sector but they must be part of an integrated climate change strategy.
Open-access content
What will Great British Energy actually do?
Mon 25 Nov 2024
The UK government is gradually unveiling details about Great British Energy, a new publicly owned energy company. So what might it look like?
Open-access content
More from 3D Modelling
Fri 25 Oct 2024
The shift toward the electrification of vehicles and the expansion of the electrical grid for renewable energy integration has led to a considerable increase in the demand for power electronics devices and modernised cable systems — applications that will help ensure a consistent and long-term electricity supply.
Sponsored by COMSOL
Open-access content
Lost Jerusalem neighbourhood recreated in 3D app
Fri 16 Jun 2023
People will be able to stroll virtually through the streets of the Mughrabi quarter of Jerusalem's Old City, thanks to a new mobile application.
Open-access content
Breathing fresh life into museum exhibits
Wed 15 Feb 2023
The nature of museum exhibitions mean they are full of history, but technology can bring the lessons of the past to life – in some cases, almost literally.
Open-access content
3D-printed food research serves up smorgasbord of edible options
Tue 7 Feb 2023
University of Florida researchers are looking at ways to 3D-print food to benefit people with health conditions, to help in humanitarian emergencies and to reduce food waste.
Open-access content
More from Construction Industry
UK government invests £68m to transform brownfield sites into land for new homes
Wed 30 Oct 2024
The UK government is to provide councils across the UK with a multi-million-pound funding boost to help unlock disused brownfield sites and get the “country building again”.
Open-access content
Comment: Labour’s ambitious planning reforms set the stage for Britain’s green energy revamp
Fri 20 Sep 2024
Longest King’s speech in decades sets ambitious planning reforms for a greener future.
Open-access content
National Highways starts trial of carbon-negative aggregate on stretch of M11 motorway
Thu 25 Jul 2024
National Highways is trialling a carbon-negative aggregate on a stretch of motorway in Essex in the hope of reducing the carbon footprint of our roads.
Open-access content
Average ‘insulation age’ of British homes is 48 years old, major study reveals
Wed 10 Apr 2024
Britain’s homes are in “urgent need” of energy efficiency updates, with a new study finding that just over half of them only meet 1970s or earlier insulation standards.
Open-access content
More from Football
Schoolgirls design the kit for the Moon’s first football team
Tue 14 Nov 2023
Two schoolgirls aged 7 and 13 have designed the official Moon United kit, in anticipation of the first-ever football match on the lunar surface.
Open-access content
Further delays to Real Madrid stadium renovation
Thu 13 Oct 2022
With the opening of the renovated Bernabeu pushed back again, will Real Madrid’s new stadium ever be ready?
Open-access content
Qatar World Cup will use semi-automated offside technology, Fifa announces
Fri 1 Jul 2022
Fifa has announced that semi-automated offside technology will be deployed at the World Cup in Qatar this winter.
Open-access content
How tech can help sport boost its green credentials
Mon 25 Oct 2021
The sports industry’s huge environmental impact means it can play a significant part in helping to achieve sustainability goals.
Open-access content
More from Sport
AI and electronic tech to replace line umpires at Wimbledon from 2025
Thu 10 Oct 2024
Breaking a 147-year tradition, the more than 300 line umpires who officiate matches during the Wimbledon championships 2025 will be replaced by Live Electronic Line Calling (Live ELC).
Open-access content
Comment: Why identity verification is key to keeping large-scale sporting events safe
Thu 12 Sep 2024
With cyber attacks increasingly targeting large-scale sporting events, Rob Otto, EMEA field CTO at Ping Identity – a global software company specialising in identity management solutions – explores why identity verification is critical to the physical and digital security of such events.
Open-access content
Paris Olympics: enhancing athlete performance with AI
Mon 22 Jul 2024
Advances in AI have made this summer’s Paris Games the most technologically advanced Olympics ever.
Open-access content
Clever ball control - new tech at the Euros
Mon 27 May 2024
Uefa has planted sensors in the ball for this summer’s European Championships to help match officials with offside and handball decisions. But will this technology solve two of football’s most contentious on-field problems?
Open-access content
More from Heidi Vella
From additives to hands free farms: Can technology decarbonise UK agriculture?
Wed 25 Sep 2024
Agriculture in the UK is becoming a climate change laggard, having made almost no reduction in emissions in nearly a decade. With government reluctant to incentivise dietary changes away from emissions-intensive foods, can technology make the difference?
Open-access content
A shot in the arm for antibiotics research
Fri 29 Mar 2024
Antimicrobial resistance is on the rise, yet no new classes of antibiotics have been discovered in decades, diminishing doctors’ arsenal in the fight against infection. Can a new wave of drug discovery targeting ‘narrow spectrum’ end the hiatus?
Members'-only content
Mon 29 Jan 2024
After a three-year hiatus, the UK has rejoined Europe’s flagship research and development fund, Horizon Europe. The news has been welcomed with relief by the R&D sector, which keenly felt its exclusion, but uncertainty remains as to whether the UK can regain its leading role within the programme.
Open-access content
How will governments regulate AI
Tue 5 Dec 2023
So how do governments hope to tame artificial intelligence with regulation – and is it even possible? Experts share their thoughts.
Members'-only content
More from Volume 19, Issue 6 - November/December 2024
News analysis: How British steel can survive in a flooded market
Thu 14 Nov 2024
faced with foreign competition, an overproduction crisis and a raft of closures, how can british steel compete in the current climate?
Open-access content
Teardown – Samsung Galaxy Ring
Mon 11 Nov 2024
This diminutive device tracks vital health signs and physical activity, but does its environmental impact override the technological advance?
Open-access content
Mentor - Skills Gap? What skills gap?
Mon 11 Nov 2024
Graham Melroy argues that universities and SMEs are not communicating, which is helping neither graduates nor the industry.
Open-access content
Editor's comment: Great British Energy promises a greener future but faces high stakes
Mon 11 Nov 2024
What do we expect from Great British Energy, the new company that was one of Labour’s flagship policies in the last UK election? Those who feared or welcomed a nationalisation of the UK’s energy industry – caught up in the momentum behind talks of re-nationalisation of the rail and water industries perhaps – can put these fears or hopes on ice, as the existing industry will continue unscathed. Instead GB Energy is merely a new kid on the block, designed to accelerate development in a greener direction.
Open-access content